top of page

How Do You Resolve Conflict Between an Employee and Their Manager?

4 hours ago
6 min read
Line Manager Conflict. Workplace Mediation. Fouchee Mediation.

By Laricelle Fouchee, Fouchee Mediation


“How can we resolve this fairly when the manager is part of the problem?” Start by giving both people a proper opportunity to explain their concerns, assess whether anything requires formal action, and identify what needs to change in the working relationship. Where direct conversations have become difficult, independent workplace mediation may help. However, the difference in authority between an employee and their manager needs careful consideration.


For HR professionals and senior leaders, these situations can be particularly uncomfortable. The manager remains responsible for performance, priorities and team delivery. The employee may depend on that same person for support, development opportunities and everyday decisions. Asking them to “have a conversation and sort it out” can underestimate what is at stake.


The aim is to understand the problem well enough to choose a fair response, while creating workable arrangements for the people involved.


Why does employee–manager conflict become difficult to resolve?


A disagreement between an employee and their manager can affect almost every part of the working day. A request for an update may feel like checking up. A short response may be interpreted as disrespect. Feedback that once seemed straightforward can become another example of an already difficult relationship.


The imbalance in authority adds another layer. An employee may worry that speaking honestly will affect their future. A manager may feel unable to challenge work without another complaint. Both can become guarded, making it harder to distinguish the immediate issue from the history surrounding it.


Recognising these pressures helps explain the difficulty. It does not establish whose account is correct.


Who should handle the concern?


Where the line manager is involved, the employee needs another credible route for raising concerns. Acas guidance recognises that a worker may approach another manager or HR, and that problems raised informally should still be taken seriously.


Consider who can respond without an inappropriate conflict of interest. Someone who has already advised extensively on the disputed events may struggle to be seen as independent. In a smaller organisation, external support may be worth considering.


Be clear about the role being undertaken. Listening to an initial concern, investigating allegations and facilitating a relationship conversation involve different responsibilities. Participants should understand which process they are entering and what information may be shared.


Listen separately before arranging a joint meeting


A joint meeting should have a clear purpose. Bringing people together too quickly can recreate the exchange that caused the difficulty, particularly if one participant feels unprepared.


Separate initial conversations help establish what each person believes has happened, how work is being affected and what response they are seeking. Ask for specific examples rather than relying on descriptions such as “controlling”, “negative” or “unprofessional”.


Useful questions include: “What happened in that conversation?”, “What effect did it have on your work?” and “What would you like to happen differently?” Check your understanding without endorsing conclusions before the relevant facts have been considered.


Distinguish relationship difficulties from matters requiring formal action


Some problems involve unclear expectations, communication habits or competing priorities. Others involve allegations that require investigation, protective measures or a formal organisational decision. These issues can also exist together.


Do not assume that a concern is merely a personality clash because the two people describe events differently. Equally, avoid treating every strained exchange as proof of misconduct.


Where a formal grievance is raised, the organisation should follow a fair formal procedure. Considering mediation does not remove that responsibility. Acas confirms both the importance of formal grievance handling and the possibility of mediation at different stages.


HR and employment lawyers can help assess the appropriate route where the issues overlap.


Recognise the power difference without assuming the outcome


An employee and manager do not enter a conversation with identical authority. That needs acknowledging in the arrangements, rather than overlooking it in the name of treating everyone the same.


Ask what would help each person participate meaningfully. This could involve preparation time, accessible information, breaks or appropriate support. Discuss concerns about what may happen after the conversation.


An employee should not be expected to negotiate away legitimate protections. A manager should also have a fair opportunity to respond and explain relevant responsibilities. The process needs room for both perspectives without assuming that responsibility for the conflict is equal.


An illustrative example: when updates become a source of tension


Imagine an employee who feels overwhelmed by repeated requests for progress updates. Their manager believes deadlines have become unreliable and needs information to answer questions from a director.


The employee starts sending brief replies and avoids asking for help. The manager responds by checking more frequently. Each person sees the other’s behaviour as confirmation of the problem: the employee feels mistrusted; the manager feels information is being withheld.


This illustrative situation might require a management decision about reporting expectations. It might also benefit from a discussion about the way requests are made and concerns are raised.


A practical arrangement could include scheduled updates, agreed indicators of delay and a clear route for requesting support. The manager receives necessary information, while the employee understands when additional questions are likely and why.


What can HR say to move the conversation forward?


A useful opening acknowledges the difficulty without deciding the outcome:


“I understand that working together has become difficult. I would like to clarify the concerns, explain the available next steps and understand what would help each of you participate.”


Where an appropriate relationship conversation follows, keep the purpose specific. “Agreeing how priorities will be communicated” is easier to work with than “improving your attitude towards each other”.


Avoid asking participants to put everything behind them before their concerns have been heard. Acknowledge the impact, then explore what a workable future arrangement would require. If the discussion becomes hostile or someone cannot participate meaningfully, pause and reassess.


When could workplace mediation help?


Workplace mediation may be useful where communication has broken down and both people are willing to explore how they could work together differently. An impartial mediator helps participants develop their own agreements rather than deciding who was right. Acas identifies relationship repair and future working arrangements as central to the process.


Independent support can be particularly useful where previous management conversations have become stuck or internal impartiality is questioned. However, an external mediator still needs to assess suitability.


Mediation should not be presented as a way to secure an apology, validate a performance concern or persuade someone to withdraw a complaint. Those expectations can undermine the conversation before it begins.


What should a useful agreement contain?


“Communicate more respectfully” expresses an intention, but leaves considerable room for different interpretations.


Discuss what the change will look like in practice. Will feedback be given privately? How will urgent work be distinguished from other tasks? Who confirms priorities when deadlines compete? What should happen if either person believes an agreement is slipping?


Record responsibilities and review arrangements in an appropriate form. Where something requires organisational approval, identify who will obtain that approval rather than implying that the participants can decide it themselves.


An agreement should also be realistic about the management relationship. Clearer communication does not remove accountability or the need for legitimate decisions about work.


How should performance concerns be handled?


Sometimes a manager believes the conflict arose because they challenged performance. The employee may believe the performance concerns are part of unfair treatment.


Avoid assuming either explanation settles the matter. Clarify the expectations, supporting evidence and relevant procedures. Consider whether workload, training, resources or support needs require attention.


A relationship conversation can help establish how feedback is exchanged, but it cannot determine whether a capability finding is justified or replace appropriate procedural handling. Keep the purpose of each process clear so that participants understand what is—and is not—being decided.


What if one person declines or the relationship does not improve?


Explore concerns about the proposed process without pressuring anyone to participate. A person may need further information or may not consider mediation appropriate.


If mediation does not proceed, consider the next suitable management or procedural response. Do not leave the working arrangements unresolved simply because one option was declined.


Where an agreement is reached, arrange a review. Ask whether the changes are happening and whether they are helping. Continued difficulties may indicate that expectations remain unclear, organisational changes are needed or another response is appropriate. The absence of a new complaint alone does not establish that the relationship has recovered.


Workplace mediation for employee–manager conflict in Durham and throughout the UK


Conflict between an employee and their manager can place considerable pressure on the people involved and the wider team. A thoughtful response starts with listening, assessing the concerns and making the next steps understandable.


My approach to workplace mediation is calm, structured and focused on practical conversations. I help participants explore their concerns, understand different perspectives and consider arrangements they can put into practice.


If you are an HR professional, senior leader or employment lawyer supporting a difficult employee–manager relationship in Durham or elsewhere in the UK, contact Fouchee Mediation to discuss whether workplace mediation could be an appropriate next step.


Useful links and sources






Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page